HP
Healthy PawsBest for fast claims
A straightforward plan with no payout caps and a reputation for quick claims.
- Unlimited payouts
- Simple plan structure
- No wellness add-on
Pet Insurance · Updated October 2026
Healthy Paws vs Lemonade (2026)
Both are popular pet insurance choices. Here's how they compare on reimbursement · deductible · annual limit, and which one fits which shopper.
The quick verdict
- Healthy Paws Best for fast claims A straightforward plan with no payout caps and a reputation for quick claims.
- Lemonade Best for low prices Lets you build a plan to fit a budget, with optional preventive care.
L
LemonadeBest for low prices
Lets you build a plan to fit a budget, with optional preventive care.
- Low starting prices
- Claims handled in the app
- Annual limits apply
Side-by-side comparison
HP | L | |
|---|---|---|
| Trustpilot rating | ||
| Reimbursement | 60–90% | Customizable |
| Annual limit | None | Customizable |
| Deductible | Annual, $100–$750 | Customizable |
| Visit site | Visit site |
Also consider
- Trupanion · Best for direct vet payment
What to compare before you choose
- Reimbursement rate. The share of a covered bill the insurer pays after the deductible, often 70% to 90%.
- Annual or per-condition. Most plans use an annual deductible. A few apply it per condition.
- Annual payout limit. Some plans cap yearly payouts. Unlimited plans cost more but protect against big bills.
- Waiting periods. Coverage for illness usually starts after a waiting period. Some orthopedic conditions wait longer.
Compare all pet insurance providers that serve your ZIP code.
Compare Pet InsuranceTrademark and logo notice: Company names, logos and trademarks are the property of their respective owners and are used only to identify each company and its products. Their appearance does not mean that any company endorses, sponsors or is affiliated with The Top 10 Experts, unless we say so. Facts were checked against public sources in October 2026; confirm current terms with the provider. Customer ratings are Trustpilot TrustScores as of October 2026, shown only for companies rated 4.0 or higher with at least 25 reviews; The Top 10 Experts is not affiliated with Trustpilot. To request a change, contact legal@thetop10experts.com.