Home Warranty review · Updated October 2026

American Home Shield Review (2026)

One of the largest home warranty companies.

Reviewed by our editorial team · How we rank · Advertising disclosure

The short version

A strong fit for older homes because it can cover some pre-existing issues. On our home warranty comparison, it's labeled Best for older homes.

Key facts

Monthly priceAbout $40–$70
Service fee$100–$125
PlansSystems, appliances, combo

What stands out

  • Can cover unknown pre-existing conditions
  • Covers rust and corrosion
  • Plans for systems, appliances or both

Pros and cons

Pros

  • Covers some pre-existing issues
  • Large contractor network

Cons

  • Higher service fees

How American Home Shield compares

Side-by-side comparison

American Home Shield
Choice Home Warranty
First American Home Warranty
Trustpilot rating––
4.0
Trustpilot · 18,107 reviews
Monthly priceAbout $40–$70About $49–$58About $49–$84
Service fee$100–$125$75–$100Varies
PlansSystems, appliances, comboBasic, TotalBasic, Premium
Visit siteVisit siteVisit site

Head-to-head comparisons

Alternatives to consider

What to check before you sign up

Whichever home warranty provider you choose, compare these points:

  • What each tier covers. Plans usually split into systems, appliances, or both. Pools, second fridges and septic are often add-ons.
  • Cost per visit. You pay a fixed trade call fee each time a technician comes out. Compare it with the monthly price.
  • Coverage limits. Most contracts cap payouts per item or per year. Read the HVAC and plumbing limits closely.
  • Pre-existing conditions. Problems that existed before coverage started and improper maintenance are commonly excluded.

See home warranty providers that serve your ZIP code.

Compare Home Warranty

Trademark and logo notice: Company names, logos and trademarks are the property of their respective owners and are used only to identify each company and its products. Their appearance does not mean that any company endorses, sponsors or is affiliated with The Top 10 Experts, unless we say so. Facts were checked against public sources in October 2026; confirm current terms with the provider. Customer ratings are Trustpilot TrustScores as of October 2026, shown only for companies rated 4.0 or higher with at least 25 reviews; The Top 10 Experts is not affiliated with Trustpilot. To request a change, contact legal@thetop10experts.com.